Dataset Table RBSM
1.
Data sourced from
32 sets of journals can be seen in Table 1:
Table
1
No |
Reference |
Name |
Size TP |
Optimal Solution |
Matrix |
1 |
(Ramadan & Ramadan, 2012) |
N01 |
3x3 |
5600 |
[Cij]3x3 = [32 40 120; 60 68 104; 200 80 60] [Si]3x1 = [20 30 45] [Dj]1x3 = [30 35
30] |
2 |
(Samuel, 2012) |
N02 |
3x4 |
28 |
[Cij]3x4 = [1 2 3 4; 4 3 2 0; 0 2 2 1] [Si]3x1 = [6 8 10] [Dj]1x3 = [4 6 8
6] |
3 |
(Karagul & Sahin, 2020) |
N03 |
5x5 |
1102 |
Cij]5x5 = [73 40 9 79 20; 62 93 96 8 13; 96 65 80 50
65; 57 58 29 12 87; 56 23 87 18 12] [Si]5x1 = [8 7 9
3 5] [Dj]1x5 = [6 8 10 4 4] |
4 |
(Kaur et al., 2018) |
N04 |
3x5 |
1580 |
[Cij]3x5 = [6 4 4 7 5; 5 6 7 4 8; 3 4 6 3 4] |
5 |
(Hussein & Shiker, 2020) |
N05 |
4x4 |
410 |
[Cij]4x4 = [7 5 9 11; 4 3 8 6; 3 8 10 5; 2 6 7 3] |
6 |
(Wireko et al., 2025) |
N06 |
3x4 |
7750 |
[Cij]3x4 = [10 8 4 3;12 14 20 2;6 9 23 25] [Si]3x1 = [500 400 300] [Dj]1x3 = [250 350 600 150] |
7 |
(Das et al., 2014) |
N07 |
3x4 |
1160 |
[Cij]3x4 = [6 1 9 3; 11 5 2 8; 10 12 4 7] |
8 |
(Murugesan & Esakkiammal, 2020) |
N09 |
4x4 |
111 |
[Cij]4x4 = [4 6 5 2; 6 4 1 4; 5 2 3 1; 4 6 7 8] |
9 |
(Amaliah et al., 2019) |
N10 |
3x4 |
910 |
[Cij]3x4 = [20 2 20 11; 24 7 9 20; 8 14 16 18] |
10 |
(Amaliah et al., 2019) |
N11 |
3x4 |
2460 |
[Cij]3x4 = [10 2 20 22; 12 7 9 40; 4 14 16 32] |
11 |
(Amaliah et al., 2019) |
N12 |
3x3 |
425 |
[Cij]3x3 = [15 7 25; 8 12 14; 17 19 21] |
12 |
(Juman & Hoque, 2015) |
N13 |
3x3 |
4525 |
[Cij]3x3 = [6 8 10; 7 11 11; 4 5 12] |
13 |
(Juman & Hoque, 2015) |
N14 |
3x4 |
920 |
Cij]3x4 = [4 6 8 8; 6 8 6 7; 5 7 6 8] [Si]3x1 = [40,
60, 50] [Dj]1x4 = [20, 30, 50, 50] |
14 |
(Ahmed et al., 2016) |
N15 |
3x4 |
156 |
[Cij]3x4 = [4 6 9 5; 2 6 4 1; 5 7 2 9] [Si]3x1 = [16 12 15] [Di]1x4 = [12 14 9 8] |
15 |
(Amreen, 2024) |
N16 |
3x4 |
1510 |
[Cij]3x4 = [22 17 25 15; 13 10 16 20; 16 19 9 5] [Si]3x1 = [30 50 50] [Di]1x4 = [30 30 50 20] |
16 |
(Gupta, 2020) |
N17 |
3x4 |
743 |
[Cij]3x4 = [19 30 50 10; 70 30 40 60; 40 8 70 20] [Si]3x1 = [7 9 18] [Di]1x4 = [5 8 7 14] |
17 |
(Goyal, 1984) |
N18 |
3x3 |
1650 |
[Cij]3x3 = [6 10 14; 12 19 21; 15 14 17 ] [Si]3x1 = [50 50 50] [Di]1x3 = [30 40 55] |
18 |
N21 |
3x3 |
4205 |
[Cij]3x3 = [135 71 260; 81 126 144; 170 189 201] [Si]3x1 = [12 17 7] [Di]1x3 = [12 10 14] |
|
19 |
(Rafi & Islam, 2020) |
N22 |
3x4 |
12075 |
[Cij]3x4 = [11 13 17 14; 16 18 14 10; 21 24 13 10] |
20 |
(Kaur et al., 2018) |
N23 |
3x4 |
23 |
[Cij]3x4 = [7 2 3 7; 1 5 4 5; 7 2 4 5] [Si]3x1 = [2 1
3] [Dj]1x4 = [2 1 1 2] |
21 |
(Juman & Hoque, 2015) |
N24 |
3x4 |
3460 |
[Cij]3x4 = [20 22 17 4; 24 37 9 7; 32 37 20 15] |
22 |
(Juman & Hoque, 2015) |
N25 |
3x4 |
809 |
[Cij]3x4 = [19 30 50 12; 70 30 40 60; 40 10 60 20] |
23 |
(G.Patel et al., 2017) |
N26 |
4x5 |
490 |
[Cij]4x5 = [20 4 6 8 9; 4 10 8 18 8; 9 11 20 40 6; 7 6
9 14 16] |
24 |
(Korukoǧlu & Balli, 2011) |
N27 |
5x5 |
59356 |
[Cij]5x5=[46 74 9 28 99; 12 75 6 36 48; 35 199 4 5 71;
61 81 44 88 9; 85 60 14 25 79] [Si]5x1=[461 277 356 488 393] [Dj]1x5=[278 60 461 116 1060] |
25 |
(M Selim Reza et al., 2019) |
N28 |
3x4 |
2090 |
[Cij]3x4=[3 1 7 4;2 6 5 9;8 3 3
2] [Si]3x1=[300 400
270] [Dj]1x4=[250 350 290 450] |
26 |
(Kousalya1 & Malarvizhi, 2016) |
N29 |
3x4 |
3857 |
[Cij]3x4 = [15 1 42 33; 80 42 26 81; 90 40 66 60] |
27 |
(Ahmed et al., 2015) |
N30 |
3x3 |
465 |
[Cij]3x3 = [13 21 14; 8 12 21; 15 17 19] [Si]3x1 = [13 20 5] [Di]1x3 = [12 15 11] |
28 |
(Kirca et al., 1990) |
N31 |
3x4 |
1480 |
[Cij]3x4 = [15 27 13 19; 18 21 24 14; 21 15 16 17] |
29 |
(Babu et al., 2020) |
N32 |
4x5 |
1780 |
[Cij]4x5 = [4 4 9 10 13;7 9 8 10 4;9 3 7 10 6;11 4 10 6
9] |
30 |
(Amreen & B, 2024) |
N33 |
3x3 |
1250 |
[Cij]3x3 = [3 3 5; 6 5 4; 6 10 7] |
31 |
(Sahito, 2021) |
N34 |
4x5 |
510 |
[Cij]4x5 = [7 6 4 5 9; 8 5 6 7 8; 6 8 9 6 5; 5 7 7 8 6] |
32 |
(Amaliah et al., 2022) |
N35 |
3x4 |
280 |
[Cij]3x4 = [1 6 5 9;3 2 4 15;8 9 3 10] [Si]3x1 = [20 25 15] [Di]1x4 = [15 15 10 20] |
2.
Data sourced from 5 sets of synthesis can
be seen in Table 2:
Table
2
No |
Name |
Size TP |
Optimal Solution |
Matrix |
1 |
S1 |
5x5 |
18855 |
[Cij]5x5 = [27 27 9 33 9; 36 15 33 30 15; 18 21 27 36 33; 33 36 21 24 9; 27 9 9 21 15] |
2 |
S2 |
5x5 |
2790 |
[Cij]5x5 = [80 80 20 100 20; 110 40 100 90 40; 50 60 80 110 100; 100 110 60 70 20; 80 20 20 60 40] |
3 |
S3 |
11x12 |
1044180 |
[Cij]11x12 = [1 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 12; 63 14 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74; 75 76 27 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86; 87 88 89 40 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98; 99 100 101 102 53 104 105 106 107 108 109 110; 111 112 113 114 115 66 117 118 119 120 121 122; 123 124 125 126 127 128 79 130 131 132 133 134; 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 92 143 144 145 146; 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 105 156 157 158; 159 160 161 162 163 164 165 166 167 118 169 170; 171 172 173 174 175 176 177 178 179 180 131 182] |
4 |
S4 |
11x12 |
92212 |
[Cij]11x12 = [13 35 30 36 35 30 30 33 31 36 15 39; 39 30 25 32 28 13 11 32 34 27 14 25; 12 39 15 11 13 30 30 31 12 25 32 13; 33 10 14 38 38 12 12 15 13 15 37 14; 37 11 25 10 14 35 29 14 33 14 37 37; 79 88 70 70 83 71 92 93 77 95 82 77; 80 98 98 84 73 91 88 86 81 78 73 73; 83 94 77 94 76 91 81 70 85 91 99 84; 78 75 78 81 79 81 81 98 83 95 88 77; 99 81 79 87 89 81 76 74 76 78 89 94; 91 83 80 92 97 97 80 89 92 71 83 99] |
5 |
S5 |
11x12 |
116020 |
[Cij]11x12 = [1 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 12; 63 14 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74; 75 76 27 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86; 87 88 89 40 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98; 99 100 101 102 53 104 105 106 107 108 109 110; 111 112 113 114 115 66 117 118 119 120 121 122; 123 124 125 126 127 128 79 130 131 132 133 134; 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 92 143 144 145 146; 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 105 156 157 158; 159 160 161 162 163 164 165 166 167 118 169 170; 171 172 173 174 175 176 177 178 179 180 131 182] |
3.
Data sourced from 5 sets of Real case XYZ
Company can be seen in Table 3:
Table
3
NO |
Data Real |
1 |
[Cij]2x94 = [22 38 32 17 31 15
23 25 25 20 33 30 18 12 23 18 26 20 15 18 15 25 28 23 16 18 21 28 20 20 25 18
18 18 25 27 21 25 23 26 33 38 29 17 38 17 39 39 22 22 35 25 28 31 33 20 36 31
23 27 25 35 30 31 28 27 28 30 27 54 43 52 56 46 59 53 40 58 44 51 40 43 45 49
48 57 46 46 60 61 66 59 55 56; 26 41 36 21 35 20 27 30 28 25 38 34 23 15 20
15 23 18 14 17 13 23 25 25 17 23 23 33 18 19 28 23 20 18 25 31 20 25 25 23 39
36 28 12 33 14 38 38 20 28 33 28 26 28 31 17 38 30 30 25 22 33 26 29 31 34 28
33 31 49 38 49 52 43 56 49 36 54 40 46 36 39 41 46 44 54 41 43 57 57 62 55 52
51] [Si]2x1 = [308252 138801] [Di]1x94 = [3852 4759 1312 3451
7537 2827 3878 15224 2530 5690 2494 2383 32901 7314 2486 0 249 2735 498 1989
4475 6091 373 5492 17978 4305 23799 1597 2773 2556 48509 3279 4183 1303 795
4024 1381 2597 1666 4848 125 0 0 10192 0 4475 3356 0 2611 2984 1368 0 1119
249 0 9447 2984 2362 125 2984 26599 746 249 0 14055 1437 2283 556 812 5786
2034 5911 5026 524 1133 464 1792 1330 1457 1668 3827 7947 297 759 9074 1436
864 2217 1160 519 4166 614 19405 30392] |
2 |
[Cij]2x94 = [22 38 32 17 31 15
23 25 25 20 33 30 18 12 23 18 26 20 15 18 15 25 28 23 16 18 21 28 20 20 25 18
18 18 25 27 21 25 23 26 33 38 29 17 38 17 39 39 22 22 35 25 28 31 33 20 36 31
23 27 25 35 30 31 28 27 28 30 27 54 43 52 56 46 59 53 40 58 44 51 40 43 45 49
48 57 46 46 60 61 66 59 55 56; 26 41 36 21 35 20 27 30 28 25 38 34 23 15 20
15 23 18 14 17 13 23 25 25 17 23 23 33 18 19 28 23 20 18 25 31 20 25 25 23 39
36 28 12 33 14 38 38 20 28 33 28 26 28 31 17 38 30 30 25 22 33 26 29 31 34 28
33 31 49 38 49 52 43 56 49 36 54 40 46 36 39 41 46 44 54 41 43 57 57 62 55 52
51] [Si]2x1 = [341015 138738] [Di]1x94 = [3332 3976
1252 3494 9871 3027 5214 20029 2437 5584 2615 2184 39154 6641 2735 0 249 2984
746 2238 4848 6837 373 4677 17447 4487 24968 1804 3137 2538 50087 3445 4375
1444 919 4024 1389 2960 1660 5221 125 0 0 11063 0 4972 3729 125 2859 5096
1492 0 871 249 125 10129 3232 2735 249 12554 28961 746 125 0 12664 1382 2405
479 724 6258 1924 5195 5217 536 924 385 2053 1111 1340 1712 3630 8300 321 679
8954 1385 862 2372 1225 480 4369 556 20814 27658] |
3 |
[Cij]2x94 = [22 38 32 17 31 15
23 25 25 20 33 30 18 12 23 18 26 20 15 18 15 25 28 23 16 18 21 28 20 20 25 18
18 18 25 27 21 25 23 26 33 38 29 17 38 17 39 39 22 22 35 25 28 31 33 20 36 31
23 27 25 35 30 31 28 27 28 30 27 54 43 52 56 46 59 53 40 58 44 51 40 43 45 49
48 57 46 46 60 61 66 59 55 56; 26 41 36 21 35 20 27 30 28 25 38 34 23 15 20
15 23 18 14 17 13 23 25 25 17 23 23 33 18 19 28 23 20 18 25 31 20 25 25 23 39
36 28 12 33 14 38 38 20 28 33 28 26 28 31 17 38 30 30 25 22 33 26 29 31 34 28
33 31 49 38 49 52 43 56 49 36 54 40 46 36 39 41 46 44 54 41 43 57 57 62 55 52
51] [Si]2x1 = [280110 138801] [Di]1x94 = [3300 4628 1250 2852
8202 2916 3912 16157 2695 5526 2699 2271 41855 7074 1616 0 125 1741 373 1243
2859 3854 249 5151 17117 4368 24291 1560 2679 2952 42223 3585 4182 1423 838
3282 1491 2324 1553 3108 125 0 125 6464 0 2859 2238 0 1616 2921 871 0 498 125
0 6091 1865 1616 125 2921 17029 498 249 0 13885 1516 2480 410 799 6616 1980
5900 4721 584 1032 419 1702 1290 1536 1725 3455 7792 341 632 9100 1269 897
2333 1296 452 3957 487 20317 32228] |
4 |
[Cij]2x94 = [22 38 32 17 31 15
23 25 25 20 33 30 18 12 23 18 26 20 15 18 15 25 28 23 16 18 21 28 20 20 25 18
18 18 25 27 21 25 23 26 33 38 29 17 38 17 39 39 22 22 35 25 28 31 33 20 36 31
23 27 25 35 30 31 28 27 28 30 27 54 43 52 56 46 59 53 40 58 44 51 40 43 45 49
48 57 46 46 60 61 66 59 55 56; 26 41 36 21 35 20 27 30 28 25 38 34 23 15 20
15 23 18 14 17 13 23 25 25 17 23 23 33 18 19 28 23 20 18 25 31 20 25 25 23 39
36 28 12 33 14 38 38 20 28 33 28 26 28 31 17 38 30 30 25 22 33 26 29 31 34 28
33 31 49 38 49 52 43 56 49 36 54 40 46 36 39 41 46 44 54 41 43 57 57 62 55 52
51] [Si]2x1 = [350910 142165] [Di]1x94 = [3512 4300 1291 3477
9394 3031 4597 22500 1776 5384 2824 2530 42638 7341 2735 0 249 2984 746 2238
4848 6837 3737 5858 16806 4210 24717 1715 2549 2520 50440 3185 4359 1437 914
3120 1551 2109 1578 5345 125 0 0 11187 0 4972 3729 125 2859 8452 1492 0 871
249 125 10317 3232 2735 249 8452 29085 746 373 0 13607 1421 2068 554 877 6207
1844 6259 4824 610 1175 403 1840 1110 1389 1739 3546 8113 348 753 8366 1329
970 2121 1181 530 3778 497 19912 34947] |
5 |
[Cij]2x94 = [22 38 32 17 31 15
23 25 25 20 33 30 18 12 23 18 26 20 15 18 15 25 28 23 16 18 21 28 20 20 25 18
18 18 25 27 21 25 23 26 33 38 29 17 38 17 39 39 22 22 35 25 28 31 33 20 36 31
23 27 25 35 30 31 28 27 28 30 27 54 43 52 56 46 59 53 40 58 44 51 40 43 45 49
48 57 46 46 60 61 66 59 55 56; 26 41 36 21 35 20 27 30 28 25 38 34 23 15 20
15 23 18 14 17 13 23 25 25 17 23 23 33 18 19 28 23 20 18 25 31 20 25 25 23 39
36 28 12 33 14 38 38 20 28 33 28 26 28 31 17 38 30 30 25 22 33 26 29 31 34 28
33 31 49 38 49 52 43 56 49 36 54 40 46 36 39 41 46 44 54 41 43 57 57 62 55 52
51] [Si]2x1 = [359746 138801] [Di]1x94 = [3269 4456 1277 2783
8888 3679 4621 18426 2745 5940 2408 2437 48268 5585 3108 0 249 3356 746 2486
5594 7707 373 4944 19086 3758 27005 1884 3139 2275 48013 3411 4479 1386 911
3405 1402 3198 1657 5967 249 0 0 12678 0 5594 4226 125 3232 7955 1616 0 995
373 125 11560 3605 3108 249 7955 32938 871 249 0 13500 1377 2189 589 752 5974
1588 6085 4578 512 1056 452 2240 1138 1268 1818 3634 8274 300 703 8162 1308
901 2438 1088 454 4199 613 19521 29812] |
Komentar
Posting Komentar